Obama opened his third presser with prepared statements addressing the swine flu crisis, the passage of the $3.4 Trillion budget resolution, economic crisis, and a short recount of his 100 days in office. Obama then proceeded to take questions from a list of pre-selected reporters creating another dull, rehearsed exchange like previous press conferences.
However, there were a few highlights… and I do mean few.
Jake Tapper kicked things off by pressing Obama on whether he believed the Bush administration authorized torture through the use of waterboarding as an interrogation technique. Citing higher ideals and values, Obama affirmed waterboarding was torture in his opinion and in the “opinion of many who’ve examined the topic.” But as is his tendency to ramble on when off-script, Obama revealed despite all his higher ideals he is firmly commited to torturing the former administration with this distraction.
First, Obama actually conceded that waterboarding might have produced valuable intelligence but quickly followed up with the position that the CIA could have gotten the information in some other “non-enhanced” way. But in a follow-up question about the classified CIA documents showing the effectiveness of enhanced interrogation techniques posed by Mark Knoller, Obama contradicts his own assertion that other techniques would have produced the same results.
I have read the documents. Now they have not been officially declassified and released. And so I don’t want to go into to the details of them. But here’s what I can tell you, that the public reports and the public justifications for these techniques, which is that we got information from these individuals that were subjected to these techniques, doesn’t answer the core question.
Which is, could we have gotten that same information without resorting to these techniques? And it doesn’t answer the broader question, are we safer as a consequence of having used these techniques?
Well, it seems like a simple matter of releasing these classified documents doesn’t it? Don’t count on it though. Do you think if “non-enhanced” CIA interrogation techniques produced actual results there would have been any need for waterboarding? It took waterboarding Kaleed Sheik Mohammed 183 times for him to spill the beans… put two and two together.